- The Debate Daily
- Posts
- Is Democracy in the UK in Crisis?
Is Democracy in the UK in Crisis?
Israel Air Strikes 🇮🇱🇾🇪 | Kemi Badenoch's Maternity Pay Controversy 🇬🇧💼 | Strictly Come Dancing 💃🕺
Welcome to today’s issue of The Debate Daily!
In today’s email: We will look at the motion of whether or not democracy in the UK is in crisis. Some argue it is in trouble due to lower turnouts in recent general elections, leading to weaker mandates. However, others suggest that direct action and strong constituency representation in Parliament suggest no democratic crisis in the UK. As we provide both sides of the argument, do you think British democracy is in crisis?
By Anu Kandel
The Headlines
Kemi Badenoch (middle)
Israel Strikes in Yemen and Lebanon: Israel launched major airstrikes on Houthi military targets in Yemen, following strikes on Hezbollah in Lebanon, as tensions rise across the region.
Kemi Badenoch's Maternity Pay Controversy: UK Business Secretary Kemi Badenoch is facing criticism for suggesting maternity pay places too much burden on businesses and calling for more "personal responsibility” on the first day of the Conservative party conference.
Strictly Come Dancing: Olympic Swimmer Tom Dean, is the first contestant to be eliminated after a public vote in Strictly Come Dancing.
Debate #017
Is Democracy in the UK in Crisis?
Due to lower political participation, the disproportional nature of First-Past-The-Post and the decreasing levels of trust in politics, it can be argued that the UK’s democracy is in crisis.
Political Participation- The 2024 general election saw the lowest turnout of 59.7% since 2001. This is compared to a turnout of 77.7% in 1992, highlighting the significant decrease in political participation in elections. This decrease threatens democracy vitally, with decreased governmental mandates after elections due to weaker political participation in recent times.
Disproportionality between votes-to-seat share - Due to the First-Past-The-Post (FPTP) system used in general elections, there is disproportionality in the votes-to-seat share. In the 2024 general election, Labour had 34% of the vote share but ended up with 63% of the seats. This results in the majority of the electorate not voting for the governing party due to the ‘winner takes all’ system, resulting in wasted votes.
Policy failures deter the electorate from voting due to the scepticism that politicians will hardly deliver on their interests.
Limited Trust – In 2023, it was reported that trust in politicians reached its lowest point in 40 years. The lack of trust indicates that politicians are not representing democracy properly and questions the legitimacy of government. Policy failures deter the electorate from voting due to the scepticism that politicians will hardly deliver on their interests.
However…
Other forms of political participation, such as direct action, the existence of voter rights and universal franchise, along with strong representation of constituents in Parliament, suggest that UK democracy is not in crisis as one may imagine.
Direct Action - There has been a rise in multiple forms of participation, such as protesting and boycotting, especially through social media among the younger generations. 70% of Gen Z are involved in a social or political cause and are the most likely generation to boycott, which has been seen recently due to the conflicts in the Middle East with young people boycotting corporations that support Israel, like Starbucks. Such forms of direct action suggest that democracy still operates well in the UK by allowing the freedom of speech and expression to prevail.
Voter Rights- The UK has universal franchise since the 1928 Equal Franchise Act, which gave women equal voting rights to women as men. Moreover, following the 1969 Representation of the People Act, all citizens over 18 have been allowed to vote since, which expanded the electorate. These laws ensure that all adult citizens can have a voice, which ensures a broader mandate across the electorate regardless of their identity.
Successful constituency representation exists, as many MPs regularly raise local issues during Parliamentary debates.
Strong Constituency Representation- The FPTP system allows each constituency to link to an MP directly. Successful constituency representation exists, as many MPs regularly raise local issues during Parliamentary debates. An example would be Daisy Cooper, the Liberal Democrat MP for St Albans, who spoke out about the healthcare services in her community and demanded help. As we witness MPs speak for their constituents and address their concerns by bringing them to Parliament, it can be argued that democracy in the UK is working.
Summary
Democracy in the UK has been a much more organic phenomenon than most democracies worldwide, taking place over hundreds of years. This has made democracy an integral value in Britain. Hence, it is safe to say that democracy as an institution is secure. However, the debate lies in whether democracy is as representative as it should be, as discussed in this article. Whilst turnout has indeed been lower in recent general elections, democracy in the UK is certainly not 'dead' with universal franchise still being upheld. This is because solid factors of democracy are still present in direct action, holding the government accountable in Prime Minister Questions and broader scrutiny.
What do you think?
How can we increase political participation among young people in the UK?
Is direct action the most effective way of democracy?
Should First-Past-The-Post be abolished for a system of greater proportional representation?
What’s on earth is going on?
Death of Hezbollah’s Leader: Consequences for Middle East
Since Friday, Hezbollah’s leader (Hassan Nasrallah) and other top executives have been killed by Israeli strikes in Lebanon.
On the one hand, Israel deems the killing as “settling the score” with Hezbollah and now continues its advance into Lebanon. With a destabilised Hezbollah, Israel believes that it can continue its offensive and re-secure its northern territories from Hezbollah threats.
On the other hand, Israel’s move into Lebanon is overextending its military resources across Gaza and Lebanon. More broadly, their offensive angers Iran further to use its militant organisations in the Middle East to counter Israel.
What does this mean:
The deaths of Hezbollah leaders do not put Israel in a better position. Regional hatred against Israel has increased for its strikes into Lebanon. With more threats looming from Iran’s allies with other militant groups, Israel would have to use other means than military ones to de-escalate the situation.
This newsletter was brought to you by Anu Kandel
Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up here.
Feedback
If you have have any questions or feedback, feel free to reach out to us directly on any of our social media, or at [email protected]
Reply