- The Debate Daily
- Posts
- Should LGBTQ+ Topics Be Taught in Schools?
Should LGBTQ+ Topics Be Taught in Schools?
Welcome to today’s issue of The Debate Daily!
In today’s email: As British society has become more accepting of the LGBTQ+ community, many have argued in favour of teaching on the subject to ensure future generations are similarly accepting and tolerant. In theory, this would foster awareness of and respect for the community, ensuring prejudices are rooted out at an early age. However, others argue that it isn’t the school’s place to teach these topics. We should instead let parents decide how to educate their children, not least if we want to respect individuals’ religions or faiths.
By Gabby Miller
The Headlines
Staffordshire Private School Closure: St Joseph’s Prep School, Stoke on Trent, has announced its closure due to financial challenges. The school will close on 31 December, making it the first private school to declare their closure, since Labour announced a plan to impose VAT on private school fees from January 1st.
Offshore Wind Farm Contracts Awarded: The UK government has awarded contracts for nine offshore wind farms after a failed auction last year. These contracts, as part of a broader green energy initiative including tidal and solar power projects, will provide enough electricity to power to fuel the equivalent of 11 million homes!
Spanish Supermarket Dating Craze: A new trend in Spain encourages single people to find partners in supermarkets using a fruit-based code, leading to some chaotic incidents that have even required police intervention to restore order.
Should LGBTQ+ topics be taught in schools?
Teaching LGBTQ+ topics in school is important because they encourage and promote a more tolerant society in which LGBTQ+ people feel safe and free to be themselves. Ensuring future generations respect the community is key to reducing prejudice and bigotry.
Tolerance - Learning about the different lives that people live allows for an increased acceptance of non-traditional lifestyles. In the long-term, this can lead to lower rates of homophobia and transphobia as children are being taught about LGBTQ+ lifestyles as normal and legitimate. Learning about these topics from a young age makes people much more accepting of people who have different relationships or family lives, ensuring they are not seen as outsiders but rather as people living ordinary lives, just like heterosexual people.
Teaching LGBTQ+ topics in school encourages those who are part of the community to feel accepted and seen, rather than outcast
Radicalisation - Some people point to the teaching of LGBTQ+ topics in schools as a form of radicalisation that will ‘turn their kids queer.’ However, there is very little evidence to suggest that this is the reality. Teaching these topics simply raises awareness of the community rather than encouraging children to change their sexual orientation or gender. Ultimately, while teaching may make children feel more comfortable identifying as LGBTQ+ in the future, it is very unlikely that they will feel pressured into identifying as something they are not.
Self-Acceptance - Teaching LGBTQ+ topics in school encourages those who are part of the community to feel accepted and seen, rather than outcast. It can allow students to better navigate personal feelings around questioning their own identity and sexual orientation thanks to being more informed. Young people, regardless of who they are, deserve to be seen within an educational curriculum and have an equal chance to be taught how to have healthy and safe relationships.
While teaching LGBTQ+ topics in schools should, in theory, have a number of positive effects, there are also issues with teaching these topics. Not everyone believes school is the right place for young people to learn about these issues, whether it is because they are ill-equipped to do so or because it is for parents to decide.
Lack of Teacher Knowledge - Many teachers do not feel fully confident teaching these topics, either because they lack the training to do so or don’t feel they have the knowledge or experience to teach LGBTQ+ topics appropriately. This means too many teachers lack the necessary expertise to handle such sensitive topics, making the potential risk of misinforming students too great. School is therefore not the right place to learn about these issues.
Many parents do not feel comfortable with their child learning about these topics and as their legal guardians, should have a say in this aspect of their lives
Parental Consent and Pushback - For some people, gender and sexual identity is a controversial topic that cannot simply be taught in a matter of fact way by schools. It should therefore be up to parents to decide whether to teach their children about these topics. Many parents do not feel comfortable with their child learning about these topics and as their legal guardians, should have a say in this aspect of their lives. This external pushback also leads to schools fearing the reaction of parents if they implement these topics, making it more problematic to teach.
Faith Schools - Faith schools may struggle to teach LGBTQ+ topics in a positive light because of incompatibility with their founding beliefs such as opposition to same-sex marriage. This creates a huge barrier to implementing this sort of teaching, especially when it comes to upholding freedom of speech and religion.
Summary
The teaching of LGBTQ+ topics in schools has recently become a controversial and hotly debated issue. On the face of it, it should promote acceptance and tolerance, allowing members of the LGBTQ+ community to feel safe and respected, especially as younger generations become more aligned with values of inclusion. However, many also believe that it is not the school’s place to teach these topics. They are arguably very difficult topics to teach and many teachers feel uncomfortable teaching them or lack the knowledge or experience necessary to properly inform students. Also important is respecting parents’ ability to choose what is best for their child. Ultimately, we must find a balance between respecting individual autonomy and respecting LGBTQ+ people.
What do you think?
Are there some LGBTQ+ topics that should be taught but others that shouldn’t?
What is the best age for children to be taught about LGBTQ+ issues and should different issues be taught at different times?
What makes it more appropriate for certain topics to be taught or discussed by parents rather than school?
Do you have friends who’d love The Debate Daily too? Send them the link below to invite them to sign up now!
This newsletter was brought to you by writer Gabby Miller and editor Kit Swift
Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up here.
Feedback
If you have have any questions or feedback, feel free to reach out to us directly on any of our social media, or at [email protected]
Reply