Is The UK Facing Too Much Legal Immigration?

Trump Assassination Attempt⚠️ | Assisted Dying Bill ⚖️ | SpaceX Crew Return🚀

Welcome to today’s issue of The Debate Daily!

In today’s email: The question over immigration in the UK was not solved by Brexit, and neither has it been resolved today. Many Britons still believe that there is mass legal immigration, causing the nation’s economic and social troubles. Meanwhile, others think this is misinformation and the immigrants who do integrate legally have a positive impact on the UK. With the UK trying to kickstart its economy and deal with anti-immigrant insurgencies, do too many legal immigrants come in?

By Jonny Ross and Ozan Anday Koyas

The Headlines

  • Trump Assassination Attempt: A man was taken into custody following what appeared to be an ‘apparent assassination attempt’ of Donald Trump near his Florida golf club. Trump is confirmed to be safe following the incident, and an AK-47-style weapon was found at the scene.

  • Assisted Dying Bill: The UK is facing a potential vote on assisted dying legislation. Public polling indicates majority support for legalisation, but political parties remain divided on the issue. No 10 has been clear that it would not block a potential bill.

  • SpaceX Crew Return: The SpaceX crew successfully returned to Earth following a historic mission featuring the world's first commercial spacewalk. The crew, led by Jared Isaacman, splashed down off the coast of Florida in the early hours of Sunday.

Debate #009

Some may argue that the UK accommodates more legal immigrants than it can muster. The UK’s government and economy are under strain, and having more immigrants could do more harm than good. Common points under this philosophy have been pressure on public services, competition of immigrants and natives in the labour force, and a social realignment of the national image.

Pressure on Public Services: Education, healthcare, and housing are sectors thought to be slightly overwhelmed by the recent flow of legal migrants. As more immigrants come to work and study, public services need to accommodate for more people. This can result in less available social housing and other government services. It is a myth however that the reasons for NHS and Housing crises are mostly due to mass legal immigration. 

Workforce Competition: Most of UK’s legal migrants come for study or work, which can create an increased domestic competition with natives. This phenomenon is the case in low-skilled labour, leading to lower wages as the pool of labour increases. In terms of other skills, the UK is dependant on middle to high skilled labour from abroad and on international students for universities. 

Education, healthcare, and housing are sectors thought to be slightly overwhelmed by the recent flow of legal migrants

Social Impact: Legal immigrants come from a variety of cultures and backgrounds which differ from the UK’s traditionally dominant caucasian base. The public opinion of Reform UK believes that this traditional identity is being rolled back as more and more immigrants arrive. Yet throughout Britain’s history, immigration has been one of the cornerstores of its identity and many immigrants adopt British traditions.

Enjoying The Debate Daily?

Click to Share!

However…

Some see that the UK is not faced at all with too much legal immigration and instead observe the positive effects of mass legal immigration: economic development, aid in public services, and building tolerance.

Economic Development: Thanks to immigrants filling skills that Britain lacks, legal migration allows a good portion of the UK economy to prosper. The wages they earn are taxed and contribute back to increasing demand and driving more business growth. The Office for National Statistics estimated that immigrants give more than 80 billion pounds to the UK economy per year.

Boosting Public Services: Legal immigration is also necessary in aiding the UK’s most lacking public services, especially in the NHS. The taxes that immigrants pay also go into government services, allowing them to stay afloat. Furthermore, tens of thousands of healthcare specialists have immigrated over to the UK and aided the crumbling NHS at its most dire times during and post the pandemic.

Legal immigration is also necessary in aiding the UK’s most lacking public services

Tolerance and Unity: The Southport insurgencies reminded the UK that a diversity of cultures and backgrounds are its strength and defining characteristic. Despite ethic and cultural differences, being British is about deep core values and traditions irrespective of skin color, religion or origin. Such a tolerant landscape is necessary to keep the UK’s democratic system healthy.

Summary

The UK’s current levels of legal immigration is unprecedented and it does to some extent cause some economic and social strain. Yet it is important to not forget that immigrants also contribute to the economy, public services, and protect Britain’s traditional liberalistic identity. The debate ongoing about immigration is only problematic because both sides are unable to understand eachother and the facts that each side has. This is the challenge which needs to be worked on if the UK is ever to move beyond the immigration question and instead start ameliorating the strength of its economy and fixing the nation.

What do you think?

1. Do I see immigration as a benefit or a burden for the UK?

2. Are immigrants boosting the economy or straining public services?

3. Is cultural diversity enriching or eroding Britain’s national identity?

What’s on earth is going on?

Russian Missiles in Ukraine: Can Ukraine Strike Back?

Russian bombs injured 30 people in Kharkiv yesterday. Yet Ukraine is unable to strike back into Russian territory due to what Putin calls NATO’s direct involvement in the war.

  • On the one side, Ukraine has encroached into Russian territory before using Western weapons and sending missiles could be yet another way to halt Russian war efforts.

  • On the other hand, Western countries are hesitating to use them in fear of further escalating the war. Ukraine is still not allowed to use them due to this worry.

This newsletter was brought to you by writers: By Jonny Ross and Ozan Anday Koyas

Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up here.

Feedback

If you have have any questions or feedback, feel free to reach out to us directly on any of our social media, or at [email protected]

Reply

or to participate.